The filing nun: Suit takes off

Police spy papers lead woman of the cloth to seek cloak of justice

By Peggy Lowe, Rocky Mountain News

December 18, 2002

 

 

Steven R. Nickerson © News

Sister Antonia Anthony says her spy file includes her participation in a protest of the International Monetary Fund and World Bank in 2000.

Related Stories

TAKE ACTION:  All Nations Alliance Calls for Accountability for Spy Files

 

1/20/03: If elected mayor, Mares would curb Denver police surveillance -- Matt Larson, The Denver Post

 

1/20/03: Mares wants a 'spy file' panel: Candidate says cops should only collect data on lawbreakers -- Kevin Vaughan, Rocky Mountain News

 

1/17/03: Citizens urge panel to probe police spy files -- Amy Herdy, Denver Pos

 

1/17/03: Public hearings urged on 'spy files' -- John C. Ensslin, Rocky Mountain News

 

1/12/03: They Know When You Are Sleeping -- Kathy Pollitt, The Nation

 

1/6/03: Spy-file scrutiny unsettles targets, Cop says citizens' worries unfounded -- Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

1/5/03: The Denver Police Get Their Say: Police intelligence activity common -- John Ingold, Denver Post

 

1/4/03: Police could take home 'spy files' -- Kevin Vaughan, Rocky Mountain News

 

1/3/03: Spy-files Policy In Dispute: City Official Says No Such Directive Existed While Zavaras Was Police Chief--Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/27/02: Denver Post seeks full disclosure of police spy files -- Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/25/02: Denver Auditor requests records on spy files -- Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/24/02: Police chief seeks internal spy-files probe: Denver spokeswoman confirms report -- Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/23/02: Former Denver Manager of Safety Tries to Wash his Hands Clean of Spy Files -- By Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/23/02: Zavaras: Spy file abuse a surprise; He believed policy was being followed in info gathering -- Owen S. Good, Rocky Mountain News

 

12/22/02: All Nation's Alliance Prods Mayoral Candidates Spy Files -- Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/21/02: Going Electronic, Denver Reveals Long-Term Surveillance --  Ford Fessenden with Michael Moss, New York Times

 

12/20/02: Group asks cost of police spy files: Auditor Mares considering probe -- Amy Herdy, Denver Post

 

12/20/02: Civil Extremists: If Dissent is a Crime, Just Lock Us Up -- Editorial, Boulder Daily Camera

12/19/02: 'Spy file' target seeks scrutiny of cops: Police didn't tell activist of rival's plot to kill him -- Amy Herdy and Carol Kreck, Denver Post

12/18/02: Spy files lacked consistent rules: Depositions indicate Denver cops didn't have clear policies -- Peggy Lowe, Kevin Vaughan and John C. Ensslin, Rocky Mountain News

12/18/02: The filing nun: Suit takes off; Police spy papers lead woman of the cloth to seek cloak of justice -- Peggy Lowe, Rocky Mountain News

 

12/18/02: Denver Spy Files: What's in the depositions -- Rocky Mountain News

 

12/18/02: Denver Spy Files: Excerpts from the depositions -- Rocky Mountain News

 

More Stories...

Sister Antonia Anthony is a 74-year-old Franciscan nun whose sideline is raising money for the poor of Mexico.

She has come across a new description for her work, courtesy of the Denver Police Department.

"I have seen my spy file," Anthony said Tuesday. "I was listed as part of the Chiapas Coalition as a criminal extremist group. I suppose when I first read that, it just seemed to me to be ludicrous."

Ludicrous and now part of a lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union on behalf of the thousands of peaceful protesters who are mentioned in the intelligence bureau's spy files.

Anthony gave an eight-hour deposition on Monday.

And she may have a real case.

As part of her file, the police cited Anthony's belief that "global financial policies are responsible for the uprisings in Chiapas, Mexico," according to a deposition given by Jean Dubofsky and viewed by the Rocky Mountain News.

"I take it we can agree that that report is based on protected First Amendment activity. Would you concur?" Anthony's lawyer asked Dubofsky, a former Colorado Supreme Court judge who sat on a panel that reviewed the files.

"Yes," Dubofsky said in the deposition.

Anthony, who lives at the Marycrest Convent in Denver, has been working with the Chiapas Coalition since 1996. The group is dedicated to helping indigenous people in Mexico's southernmost state.

Anthony said the intelligence report's recitation of her belief was correct.

"I think it's an issue to be looked at, not something to be condemned for," she said.

But those beliefs have never led her to commit violence, not even property damage, during the many protests she's attended, Anthony said.

Her most radical act of late was helping raise $8,500 to buy a rice-husking machine for a Mexican village.

While she understands that police may need to keep intelligence files, Anthony said there's a significant line that shouldn't be crossed.

"I just would say that, of course, nobody wants real terrorists to be walking the streets or doing terrorist activities," she said.

"But I think it's so important to distinguish between that and people who protest because of real legitimate issues."

 

 

 FAIR USE NOTICE
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
 

Hit Counter